Same-day service • 60-minute response

Recent Work • Greenwood, IN • Tankless Water Heater Installation

Tankless Water Heater Installation in Greenwood, IN

A Greenwood homeowner lost hot water on a Sunday morning with a 12-year-old 50-gallon gas tank leaking at the base. We drained and removed the old unit, upsized the gas line, ran new stainless venting and commissioned a wall-hung tankless unit the same day.

Carter's My Plumber technician installing a wall-hung tankless water heater

City

Greenwood, IN

Service

Tankless install

Home

2-story, 4 bath

On site

Same day

Warranty

Parts & labor

Job Report

Call receivedSunday morning — no hot water, water on the utility room floor
Existing equipment50-gallon natural gas tank water heater, 12 years old
Failure modeCorroded tank seam leaking at the base; anode rod fully consumed
Homeowner goalStop the leak today and never run out of hot water again
InstalledWall-hung condensing natural gas tankless water heater
Supporting workGas line upsize, new stainless vent run, isolation valve kit
PermittingHandled per Johnson County requirements for the scope of work

What We Found On Arrival

The utility room floor was wet across roughly a six-foot area and the tank jacket was rusted through near the base weld. A leak at that seam is not repairable — once the glass lining fails, the tank is done.

Before quoting anything we shut off the gas and the cold supply, drained the tank down and checked the surrounding drywall and subfloor for damage so the homeowner knew the full picture up front.

Water shutoff
Isolated at the cold inlet, tank drained to a floor drain
Gas supply
1/2" branch — undersized for tankless demand
Venting
Existing B-vent through the chimney chase
Floor damage
Surface water only, no subfloor rot
Plumber working on the gas and water lines outside a Greenwood, Indiana home

What Our Plumber Found

01

Tank Seam Corrosion

The bottom weld had rusted through. Sediment buildup over 12 years accelerated the corrosion and the anode rod was completely spent.

02

Undersized Gas Branch

The half-inch branch feeding the old tank could not support the BTU demand of a whole-home tankless unit. It had to be upsized.

03

Wrong Venting Type

A condensing tankless unit cannot share the old B-vent. It needs a dedicated stainless or PVC run with its own termination.

04

No Isolation Valves

The original install had no service valves, which makes flushing impossible. The new install got a full isolation valve kit.

Technician checking the water line at a Greenwood home before the tankless install

What We Installed

We removed the failed tank, freed up the floor space entirely and mounted a condensing natural gas tankless unit on the wall. The gas branch was upsized, a dedicated vent was run to a new sidewall termination, and the unit was commissioned and tested against the home's actual fixture load.

  • UnitCondensing natural gas tankless water heater
  • Gas lineUpsized branch with new sediment trap and shutoff
  • VentingDedicated stainless run, sidewall termination
  • WaterIsolation valve kit with flush ports
  • CondensateNeutralizer routed to the floor drain

Work Log

We document the job chronologically so homeowners can see exactly what goes into the work.

  1. 8:10 AM

    Call answered

    Live dispatch took the call and put the home in the first available window.

  2. 9:25 AM

    Technician on site

    Gas and water isolated, tank drained, damage assessed and photographed.

  3. 9:50 AM

    Options presented

    Flat-rate quotes for a like-for-like tank and for a tankless conversion, side by side.

  4. 10:30 AM

    Old tank removed

    Tank hauled out, area cleaned and dried, mounting location laid out.

  5. 12:15 PM

    Gas and vent work

    Gas branch upsized with a new sediment trap, dedicated vent run to the sidewall.

  6. 2:40 PM

    Unit mounted and piped

    Tankless unit hung, water piped through the isolation kit, condensate neutralizer set.

  7. 4:05 PM

    Commissioning

    Gas pressure verified, unit fired, temperature rise tested at multiple fixtures.

  8. 4:45 PM

    Walkthrough

    Homeowner shown the shutoffs, flush ports and maintenance schedule.

Final Testing & Verification

  • Gas pressure checked static and under load
  • All gas joints leak-tested
  • Vent termination clearances verified
  • Temperature rise tested at the furthest fixture
  • Two fixtures run simultaneously to confirm flow
  • Condensate drainage confirmed
  • Work area cleaned and old unit hauled away

Permit and inspection requirements are handled according to the local jurisdiction and project scope.

The Result

The home went from no hot water at 8 AM to endless hot water the same evening, with the utility room floor space back and a unit rated for a far longer service life than the tank it replaced.

  • DowntimeSame day — no overnight without hot water
  • Floor space recoveredRoughly 9 square feet
  • Simultaneous fixturesTwo showers plus a sink, tested
  • MaintenanceAnnual flush, scheduled with the homeowner

What Homeowners Can Learn From This Job

Rust at the base is the end of the road

Once you see rust weeping at the bottom seam, the tank is failing. Repairs at that point buy days, not years.

Tankless is not a straight swap

Gas sizing and venting almost always change. A quote that ignores those two items is not a real quote.

Ask for isolation valves

Without service valves you cannot flush the unit, and skipped flushes are the fastest way to lose a tankless warranty.

Anode rods matter

On tank heaters, replacing the anode rod every few years is the cheapest thing you can do to extend the tank's life.

We're Local

60-Minute Response Time

Give us a call for service you can trust

Technicians available now. Live customer service standing by.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a tankless water heater installation take?

A straightforward conversion is typically a same-day job. Gas line upsizing and new venting add hours, which is why we quote the full scope before we start.

Is tankless worth it in an Indiana home?

Groundwater here runs cold in winter, so unit sizing matters. Sized correctly, you get endless hot water and a longer service life than a tank. Sized poorly, you get lukewarm showers in January.

Do I need a bigger gas line?

Usually yes. Most tank heaters run on a half-inch branch, and whole-home tankless units need more. We verify the load before we quote.

What maintenance does it need?

An annual descaling flush, which is quick when isolation valves are installed. Central Indiana's hard water makes this non-negotiable.

This write-up documents work of this type completed in the Greenwood area. Job details, equipment and timing vary from home to home.

Average pickup: 12 seconds

60-Minute ResponsePlumbers Standing By.

25,000+ Homes Serviced · 50+ Years Experience · 2,800+ Google Reviews

Call (317) 434-3980

Book Now

Tell us what's going on and we'll reach out fast.

Step 1 of 425%

What's going on with your plumbing?

Select all that apply.

Or call us 24/7 at (317) 434-3980

(317) 434-3980· Tap to Call